BEFORE THE OIL AND GAS CONSERVATION COMMISSION

OF THE STATE OF COLORADO

IN THE MATTER OF CHANGES TO THE RULES AND                                                     )         CAUSE NO. 1R

REGULATIONS OF THE OIL AND GAS CONSERVATION                                               )   

COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF COLORADO                                                                )         ORDER NO. 1R-100

REPORT OF THE COMMISSION

                        Pursuant to a hearing before the Oil and Gas Conservation Commission on December 5, 2005, in Suite 801, 1120 Lincoln Street, Denver, Colorado, the Oil and Gas Conservation Commission promulgated amendments to its Rules and Regulations as described below:

DRILLING, DEVELOPMENT, PRODUCING AND ABANDONMENT

(300 Series)

318A. GREATER WATTENBERG AREA SPECIAL WELL LOCATION, SPACING AND UNIT DESIGNATION RULE

a. GWA, GWA wells, GWA windows and unit designations. The Greater Wattenberg Area ("GWA") is defined to include those lands from and including Townships 2 South to 7 North and Ranges 61 West to 69 West, 6th P.M. In the GWA, operators may utilize the following described surface drilling locations ("GWA windows") to drill, twin, deepen, or recomplete a well ("GWA well") and to commingle any or all of the Cretaceous Age formations from the base of the Dakota Formation to the surface:

(1) A square with sides four hundred (400) feet in length, the center of which is the center of any governmental quarter-quarter section ("400’ window"); and,

(2) A square with sides eight hundred (800) feet in length, the center of which is the center of any governmental quarter section ("800’ window").

  • (3) Absent a showing of good cause, which shall include the existence of a surface use or other agreement with the surface owner authorizing a surface well location outside of a GWA window, all surface wellsites shall be located within a GWA window.

  •                     (4) Unit designations.

    A. 400’ window. When completing a GWA well in a 400’ window to a spaced formation, the operator shall designate drilling and spacing units in accordance with existing spacing orders.

    B. 800’ window. When completing a GWA well in an 800’ window, whether in spaced or unspaced formations, the operator shall: (i) designate drilling and spacing units in accordance with existing spacing orders where units are not smaller than a governmental quarter section; or (ii) form a voluntary drilling and spacing unit consisting of a governmental quarter section; or (iii) where designating a drilling and spacing unit smaller than a governmental quarter section, secure waiver(s) from the operator or from the mineral owners (if the operator is also the holder of the mineral lease) of the lands in the governmental quarter section that are not to be included in the spacing unit; or (iv) apply to the Commission to form an alternate unit or to respace the area.

    C. Unspaced areas and wellbore spacing units. When completing a GWA well to an unspaced formation, the operator shall designate a drilling and spacing unit not smaller than a governmental quarter-quarter section if such well is proposed to be located greater than four hundred sixty (460) feet from the quarter-quarter section boundary in which it is located. If a well is proposed to be located less than four hundred sixty (460) feet from the governmental quarter-quarter section boundary, a wellbore spacing unit ("wellbore spacing unit") for such well shall be comprised of the four (4) governmental quarter-quarter sections nearest to the wellbore regardless of section or quarter section lines.

    b. Recompletion/commingling of existing wells. Any GWA well in existence prior to the effective date of this rule, which is not located as described above, may also be utilized for deepening to or recompletion in any Cretaceous Age formation and for the commingling of production therefrom.

    c. Surface locations. Prior to the approval of any Application for Permit-to-Drill submitted for a GWA well, the proposed surface well location shall be reviewed in accordance with the following criteria:

    (1) A new surface well location shall be approved in accordance with Commission rules when it is less than fifty (50) feet from an existing surface well location.

    (2) When the operator is requesting a surface well location greater than fifty (50) feet from a well (unless safety or mechanical considerations of the well to be twinned or topographical or surface constraints justify a location greater than fifty (50) feet), the operator shall provide a consent to the exception signed by the surface owner on which the well is proposed to be located in order for the Director to approve the well location administratively.

    (3) If there is no well located within a GWA window but there is an approved exception location well located outside of a GWA window that is attributed to such window, the provisions of subsections (1) and (2) of this subsection c. shall be applicable to such location.

    d. Prior wells excepted. This rule does not alter the size or configuration of drilling units for GWA wells in existence prior to the effective date of this rule. Where deemed necessary by an operator for purposes of allocating production, such operator may allocate production to any drilling and spacing unit with respect to a particular Cretaceous Age formation consistent with the provisions of this rule.

    e. GWA infill. This subsection applies to the following area of the GWA: Township 1 North, Ranges 66 West through 68 West; Township 1 North, Range 69 West: E˝; Township 2 North, Ranges 64 West through 68 West; Township 2 North, Range 69 West: E˝; Township 3 North, Ranges 64 West through 67 West; Township 4 North, Ranges 63 through 67 West; Township 5 North, Ranges 63 West through 67 West; Township 6 North, Ranges 63 West through 66 West, 6th P.M.

    (1) Interior infill wells. Additional bottom hole locations for the "J" Sand, Codell and Niobrara Formations are hereby established greater than four hundred sixty (460) feet from the outer boundary of any existing 320-acre drilling and spacing unit ("interior infill wells"). Pursuant to the well location provisions of subsection a., above, interior infill well locations shall be reached by utilizing directional drilling techniques from the GWA windows.

    A. If a bottom hole location for an interior infill well is proposed to be located less than four hundred sixty (460) feet from the outer boundary of an existing drilling and spacing unit, a wellbore spacing unit as defined in a.(3)C., above, shall be designated by the operator for such well.

    B. If a bottom hole location for an interior infill well is proposed to be located greater than four hundred sixty (460) feet from an existing 80-acre or existing 320-acre drilling and spacing unit, the spacing unit for such well shall conform to the existing 80-acre or existing 320-acre drilling and spacing unit.

    (2) Boundary wells. Additional bottom hole locations for the "J" Sand, Codell and Niobrara Formations are hereby established less than four hundred sixty (460) feet from the outer boundary of a 320-acre governmental half section or from the outer boundary of any existing 320-acre drilling and spacing unit ("boundary wells"). A wellbore spacing unit as defined in a.(3)C., above, shall be designated by the operator for such well.

    (3) Additional producing formations. An operator wanting to complete an interior infill well or boundary well in a formation other than the "J" Sand, Codell, or Niobrara Formations ("additional producing formation") must request an exception location prior to completing the additional producing formation. The spacing unit dedicated to the exception location shall comply with subsections (1) or (2), above, as appropriate.

    (4) Water well sampling. The Director shall require initial baseline testing prior to the first interior infill well or boundary well ("proposed GWA infill well") drilled within a governmental section. The following shall be used as guidance for the Director in establishing initial baseline testing:

    A. Within the governmental quarter section of the proposed GWA infill well, the closest water well ("water quality testing well") completed in the Laramie/Fox Hills Aquifer shall be sampled.

    B. If no Laramie/Fox Hills water wells are located within the governmental quarter section, then the deepest representative water quality testing well within the governmental quarter section of the proposed GWA infill well shall be sampled.

    C. If no water wells are located within the governmental quarter section, a water quality testing well (preferably completed in the Laramie/Fox Hills Aquifer) within one-half (˝) mile of the proposed GWA infill well shall be selected.

    D. If there are no water quality testing wells that meet the foregoing criteria, then initial baseline testing shall not be required.

    E. Initial baseline testing shall include laboratory analysis of all major cations and anions, total dissolved solids, iron and manganese, nutrients (nitrates, nitrites, selenium), dissolved methane, pH, and specific conductance.

    F. If free gas or a methane concentration level greater than 2 mg/l is detected in a water quality testing well, compositional analysis shall be performed to determine gas type (thermogenic, biogenic or an intermediate mix of both). If the testing results reveal biogenic gas, no further isotopic testing shall be required. If the testing results reveal thermogenic gas, carbon isotopic analyses of methane carbon shall be conducted. The Director may require further water well sampling at any time as a result of the laboratory results or in response to complaints from water well owners.

    G. Copies of all test results described above shall be provided to the Director and the landowner where the water quality testing well is located within three (3) months of collecting the samples used for the test. Laboratory results shall also be submitted to the Director in an electronic format.

    (5) Existing production facilities. To the extent reasonably practicable, operators shall utilize existing roads, pipelines, tank batteries and related surface facilities for all interior infill wells and boundary wells.

    (6) Notice and hearing procedures. For proposed boundary wells, wellbore spacing units, and additional producing formations provided by this subsection e., the following process shall apply:

    a. Notice shall be given by certified mail by the operator of a proposed boundary well or wellbore spacing unit to all owners in the proposed wellbore spacing unit. Notice shall be given by certified mail by the operator of a proposed additional producing formation to all owners in cornering and contiguous spacing units of the requested completion and the proposed spacing unit; if the additional producing formation is unspaced only the owner in the proposed spacing unit needs to be notified.

    b. Each owner shall have a twenty (20) day period after receipt of such notice to object in writing to the operator to such well location, proposed spacing unit, or additional producing formation. If a timely objection is received, the matter shall be set on the docket at the next available Commission hearing. Absent receipt of an objection by the operator from an owner within such twenty (20) day period, the Director may administratively approve the boundary well, wellbore spacing unit, or additional producing formation, provided that it does not exceed eight (8) producing completions in the "J" Sand, Codell or Niobrara Formations in the 160-acre governmental quarter section as set forth in subsection f. below. A location plat evidencing the well location, wellbore spacing unit, or additional producing formation and applicable spacing unit shall be submitted to the Director together with copies of any surface waivers and a certification that no timely objections were received. An Application for Permit-to-Drill, Form 2, specifically identifying that a boundary well, a wellbore spacing unit, or an additional producing formation is proposed, shall also be filed with the Director in accordance with Rule 303.

    (7) The Commission shall review the effectiveness of this subsection e. no later than March 1, 2008 and may require operators to submit data related to infill drilling performed under this subsection.

    f. Limit on locations. This rule does not limit the number of formations that may be completed in any GWA drilling and spacing unit nor, subject to subsection c., above, does it limit the number of wells that may be located within the GWA windows. However, absent Commission order otherwise, there shall be no more than eight (8) producing completions in the "J" Sand, Codell or Niobrara Formations in any 160-acre governmental quarter section.

    g. GWA water sampling. The Director may apply appropriate drilling permit conditions to require water well sampling near any proposed GWA wells in accordance with the guidelines set forth in subsection e.(4), above.

    h. Exception locations. The provisions of Rule 318.c. respecting exception locations shall be applicable to GWA wells, however, absent timely objection, boundary wells, wellbore spacing units, and additional producing formations shall be administratively approved as provided in subsection e.(6) above.

    i. Correlative rights. This rule shall not serve to bar the granting of relief to owners who file an application alleging abuse of their correlative rights to the extent that such owners can demonstrate that their opportunity to produce Cretaceous Age formations from the drilling locations herein authorized does not provide an equal opportunity to obtain their just and equitable share of oil and gas from such formations.

    j. Supersedes orders and policy. Subject to paragraph d. above, this rule supersedes all prior Commission drilling and spacing orders affecting well location and density requirements of GWA wells and supersedes and replaces the "Policy on Staff Administrative Application of the Greater Wattenberg Area Well Location Rule 318A.," dated April 26, 1999.

    Attached, as Exhibit A, is a statement giving the basis and purpose of the revisions and such statements are incorporated herein by reference.

     

                            DONE AND PERFORMED by the Oil and Gas Conservation Commission of the State of Colorado this day of December, 2005.

    IN THE NAME OF THE COLORADO

    OIL AND GAS CONSERVATION COMMISSION

    OF THE STATE OF COLORADO

                                                                          By  __________________________________________

                                                                                                    Patricia C. Beaver, Secretary

    Dated at Suite 801

    1120 Lincoln Street

    Denver, Colorado 80203

    December 5, 2005

    Exhibit A

    Statement of Basis and Purpose

    This statement sets forth the basis, specific authority, and purpose for the amendments to Rule 318A. of the Rules and Regulations ("Rules" or, individually, "Rule") of the Colorado Oil and Gas Conservation Commission ("Commission"), 2 CCR 404-1. This statement is hereby incorporated by reference in the amendments adopted.

    AUTHORITY

    These Rules are adopted by the Commission under the provisions of Title 34, Article 60 of the Colorado Revised Statutes, as amended, specifically, the "Oil and Gas Conservation Act," §§ 34-60-101 et seq., C.R.S. (2005).

    §34-60-102(1), C.R.S., declares that it is in the public interest to foster, encourage, and promote the development, production, and utilization of the oil and gas resources in the State of Colorado in a manner consistent with protection of public health, safety, and welfare.

    §34-60-102(1), C.R.S., declares that the General Assembly intends to promote the development of oil and gas resources in Colorado by, among other things, prohibiting waste and permitting "each oil and gas pool in Colorado to produce up to its maximum efficient rate of production…."

    §34-60-102(1), C.R.S., declares that it is the public interest to safeguard, protect, and enforce the coequal and correlative rights of owners and producers in a common source or pool of oil and gas.

    §34-60-103(6.5), C.R.S. defines "Oil and gas operations" to mean exploration for oil and gas, including the conduct of seismic operations and the drilling of test bores; the siting, drilling, deepening, recompletion, reworking, or abandonment of an oil and gas well, underground injection well, or gas storage well; production operations related to any such well including the installation of flowlines and gathering systems; the generation, transportation, storage, treatment, or disposal of exploration and production wastes; and any construction, site preparation, or reclamation activities associated with such operations.

    §34-60-105(1), C.R.S. provides that "The commission has jurisdiction over all persons and property, public and private, necessary to enforce the provisions of this article, and has the power to make and enforce rules, regulations, and orders pursuant to this article, and to do whatever may reasonably be necessary to carry out the provisions of this article. . . ."

    §34-60-106(2)(a), C.R.S. provides that the Commission has the authority to regulate "[t]he drilling, producing and plugging of wells and all other operations for the production of oil or gas . . . ."

    §34-60-106(2)(c), C.R.S. provides that the Commission has the authority to regulate "the spacing of wells . . . ."

    §34-60-106(2)(d), C.R.S. gives the Commission authority to regulate "[o]il and gas operations so as to prevent and mitigate significant adverse environmental impacts on any air, water, soil or biological resource to the extent necessary to protect public health, safety, and welfare, in consideration of cost-effectiveness and technical feasibility."

    §34-60-106(11), C.R.S. mandates the Commission to "promulgate rules and regulations to protect the health, safety and welfare of the general public in the conduct of oil and gas operations."

    §34-60-116(1), C.R.S. authorizes the Commission to prevent waste and avoid the drilling of unnecessary wells by establishing "drilling units."

    §34-60-116(4), C.R.S. authorizes the Commission to prevent waste and avoid the drilling of unnecessary wells by increasing or decreasing the size of drilling units or by permitting additional wells to be drilled within established drilling units.

     

    B. PURPOSE

    300 Series

    The 300 Series of the Rules pertain to location, drilling, development, producing and abandonment of oil and gas operations.

    In April 1998, the Commission promulgated Rule 318A ("GWA Rule"), the Greater Wattenberg Area ("GWA") Special Well Location Rule, pursuant to Order No. 1R-84. The purpose of the GWA Rule was "to facilitate the maximum efficient recovery of oil and gas from the Cretaceous Age formations by authorizing the use of any previously designated drilling window for production from any or all of such formations." Order No. 1R-84, Exhibit A, Statement of Basis and Purpose at ¶3. On April 26, 1999, the Commission approved and adopted a policy relating to interpretation and administrative application of the GWA Rule entitled, "Policy on Staff Administrative Application of the Greater Wattenberg Area Special Well Location Rule 318A" ("Policy").

    The Commission is amending the GWA Rule, consistent with the original purpose of the GWA Rule and Policy, and in light of data gathered by operators that indicate significant amounts of gas-in-place are not being recovered. The purposes of the amendments are to increase the number of potential bottom hole locations in portions of the GWA and to eliminate the need for the Policy.

    The amendments limit the location of surface wellsites, reduce well-twinning distances and provide for directional drilling from existing surface drilling windows consistent with the intent of the General Assembly to "foster, encourage and promote" the development of oil and gas "in a manner consistent with protection of public health, safety, and welfare." C.R.S. § 34-60-102(1).

    These amendments protect the correlative rights of offset owners by requiring operators to form "wellbore spacing units" and provide notice to adjacent mineral owners (who are afforded an opportunity to be heard) when infill wells encroach on boundaries of sections and existing drilling and spacing units. These provisions are consistent with the intent of the General Assembly to protect coequal and correlative rights in common pools of oil and gas. C.R.S. § 34-60-102(1).

    Add new language to describe an area within the GWA for the location and conditions for drilling infill wells to and commingling production from the "J" Sand, Codell and Niobrara Formations. Add language to establish drilling and spacing units for infill wells. Add language to establish notice and hearing procedures for infill wells that encroach on boundaries of section lines and existing drilling and spacing units. Add language that requires water well testing in the infill area and allows the Director discretion to require water well testing in the Greater Wattenberg Area as a whole. Add new language to incorporate the Policy.